Back to home

Vinted First, Shops Second. How I Buy Board Games.

Brand-new board games for 20% of their retail price? It happens. Here's how I hunt for games on Vinted, negotiate prices, and why a missing component in my latest purchase hasn't put me off the second-hand market.

Board game boxes, a yellow pirate ship without a mast, and a phone displaying second-hand listings

When a board game catches my eye, I don’t immediately start looking for the cheapest shop. I check Vinted first. I have a list of games I’d like to add to my collection, and those are the titles I look for. Nothing particularly complicated about it. If I find an interesting offer, I try negotiating the price.

I don’t buy everything just because it’s cheap. I look for specific games and try not to spend more than I need to. And the price differences can be pretty substantial. I’ve even managed to buy brand-new copies for around one fifth of their retail price.

Buying second-hand does mean trusting the seller to some extent. And sometimes you open the box only to find that something’s missing.

First the Wishlist, Then the Hunt on Vinted.

A low price alone isn’t enough to make me buy a game. Otherwise I’d end up collecting discounts instead of board games. I’d need a barcode scanner to play. I look for titles on my list, and when a suitable listing comes along, I check the price and try to negotiate.

Vinted is my first stop. That doesn’t mean I’ll buy every game there, though. If an offer isn’t good enough, I see no reason to go for it just because someone has listed the game as used.

Some titles are practically impossible to find in regular shops anymore. In those cases, the second-hand market is what’s left. I still check the price, of course, but there’s not much point waiting for a shop discount when the shops no longer have it. First, I have to find the game at all.

The Price of the Game Isn’t Everything. Shipping and Fees Count Too.

I don’t get particularly excited about the price shown in a listing. On Vinted, you still need to add the platform fees and shipping costs. Only then do you know how much you’re actually going to pay. On Vinted, the listing price is the base game, while shipping and fees are mandatory expansions.

I use Allegro for comparison, where I have the Smart delivery subscription. If I find a brand-new copy on Vinted and it’s still cheaper than a new copy on Allegro after all the extra costs are included, buying it makes sense to me. If the price difference disappears once the fees are added, the deal suddenly looks much less attractive.

That’s why negotiating matters. Sometimes it’s what determines whether I end up buying the game on Vinted or whether I’m better off looking elsewhere.

A Brand-New Board Game for One Fifth of the Price? It Happens!

You can find brand-new games on Vinted too, not just used ones. Those are the listings where I have managed to save quite a bit.

I’ve managed to buy Pandemic: The Cure and Kości Obfitości this way, for example. Both games were new, and I paid around 20% of the price of new retail copies. In other words, roughly one fifth of what I’d normally have had to spend. At prices like that, it looks as though someone priced the rulebook and threw in the rest of the box for free.

I’m not saying you can buy every board game at that kind of discount. These opportunities simply come along sometimes. You have to search, compare listings, and occasionally negotiate. For me, that’s reason enough to check what’s available on Vinted before buying from a shop.

Tiny Epic Pirates, or What Happens When a Mast Is Missing from the Box.

Recently, I bought Tiny Epic Pirates for less than half the price of a new copy. According to the listing, the game was supposed to be complete. But when I opened the box, something didn’t add up.

When I checked the contents, I discovered that one mast was missing from the yellow pirate ship. The yellow ship got the budget-airline treatment. The mast counted as extra baggage.

Is it a huge problem for me? Not really. In my experience, the masts make it much harder to load goods onto the ships, so I probably won’t use them anyway. At least with the way I use the game, the missing mast doesn’t seem to interfere with gameplay. I haven’t checked whether it might be needed in some particular game variant, though.

But it was supposed to be complete. Sure, I paid less than half the price of a new copy, but the listing said it was complete. I’d still like to have every component that should be in the box, even if I probably won’t use that particular mast.

So I reported the missing mast to the seller on Vinted. I don’t know how it will turn out yet. I’m not making a massive issue out of it, but I’d still like to have a complete game.

I’ll Keep Buying Used Games, but I’ve Learned One Lesson.

Until now, my approach has been pretty simple. If a seller said a game was complete, I generally trusted them. If a copy was still sealed in plastic, I assumed everything was probably fine. I treated the shrink-wrap like a notary, even though it had never looked inside the box.

I don’t always have time to check the contents as soon as a parcel arrives. Sometimes the box just has to wait. And until I open it and count the components, I can’t really know whether anything’s missing.

After buying Tiny Epic Pirates, I think I’ll start checking everything sooner. Other than that, nothing changes: I’ll keep checking Vinted, looking for titles on my list, negotiating and comparing prices with Allegro.

With savings like these, the second-hand market still makes a lot of sense to me. You just have to remember that a low price doesn’t guarantee a perfect set of contents. And I think I’ll simply start checking inside the box a little sooner.

Photo of Wojtek Jakieła

Thanks for stopping by.

Have a question, an idea for a post, or just want to say hello? Send me an email. You can also find me on Facebook, YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, LinkedIn, X, Threads, Bluesky and Mastodon.

Stay in the loop

Want to know when a new post is out? I will send a browser notification. No e-mail or account, and you can turn it off with one click.